Campus Carry, Not Scary
Why does California State Senator Lois Wolk choose to be ignorant? With her representing a college town you would hope otherwise.
Wolk is campaigning to largely prevent the few folks with California concealed carry licenses (CCW) from exercising the right on campuses (the bill as currently drafted, subject to change no doubt, leaves it up to schools to set policy). Ignoring how this creates legal jeopardy for CCW holders unaware of shifting restrictions from place to place, the bigger question is “why?” The empirical data does not support the need to discriminate as Wolk wants to do.
In our recent Non-Brady State Scorecard report (ED: alas, no longer being published), we discovered that states that allow CCW holders to carry on campuses, both K12 public schools and college campuses, had significantly lower violent crime rates, including firearm homicides and all forms of murder. The effect is amplified in “college campus carry” states, indicating that a fair amount of murder, rape, robbery and assault that happens on or near college campuses is suppressed by the possibility of armed response.
In her own words, Wolk thinks “As concealed weapons permits are becoming more prevalent and easier to obtain, campus public safety officials need more authority to regulate them on campus grounds.” Yet her statement is made without justification. What precisely is the danger posed by CCW holders? Statistics tell us the opposite effect is in play; that CCW holders not only fail to cause problems, their very presence suppresses violent acts. In states where college campuses allow CCW holders equal access, murders are 37% lower, rapes are 11% less frequent, robbery drops 47% and aggravated assaults plunge 36%. Even firearm homicides drop 33%.
In the absence of a measurable problem, Wolk – like every politician before her – uses fear to motivate votes. But the empirical data shows that CCWs on campus is a non-existent problem and possibly part of the solution. This is what we know about CCW holders, from the available data:
- CCW holders have amazingly low violent crime rates, often lower than police officers in the same states where CCWs are the norm.
- People who take the time to get a CCW are not hot heads who misuse guns, hence they do not contribute to crime levels.
- Numerous incarcerated felon studies have shown the one thing thugs really hate are armed victims. Hence, if a co-ed might be armed, her rapist or mugger is far less likely to act on his criminal impulses.
The proper voter action at this point is to ignore Wolk and other fear mongers, and to insist on equal self-protection rights.
Does the above graph represent overall drops in crime in states with both CCW and campus carry, or drops in campus crime exclusively?
The stats are state wide, not campus only.
I would like to find a quality crime rate data set for campuses and surrounding areas, but have not yet located one.
Didn’t Brown sign this bad Bill into law? Effectively removing the few people that might stop a mass shooting and telling anyone that wants to commit mass murder to go to college campuses, no one will be armed.
@David: Yep. I don’t have the details at my finger tips, but that is the case. Not that CCWs are in abundance in California, but the few defacto shall issue counties with colleges are now out in the cold.
I Currently work as a Campus Safety Officer, Unarmed and usually alone
If a ACTIVE-SHOOTER comes to this Campus, I’m defenseless and the staff and students are all in harm’s way boy I would greatly welcome CCW holders
I feel for you Joe. Being in the San Francisco are for 20 years, I long to live anywhere that CCWs were available.
As a long standing CCW holder I would like to find accurate information on the new 1000 foot rule as it applys to CCW holders. It seems to prohibit any carrying within 1000 feet of any school or college. If that is so it would be impossible to go anywhere in my area since there are schools all over. I am confused.
David, the first resource I found (and it looks to be well reviewed) is:
Bottom line is that if the state you are in allows CCWs to carry on campuses, then you are OK. If not, then it is a violation of Federal law (rather unconstitutional federal law since nothing in the constitutional grants the feds such jurisdiction … though that appears to be a non-barrier these day).
But, if campus carry is illegal in you state, in theory you have to unload and stow your gun if driving past a school. Ugly piece of legislation if I’m reading it correctly.